BEING SO GOOD My dad got married late in life; he was 45, my mom 38. I think they were both surprised that they weren't going to be single forever, and they wasted no time in starting the family. I appeared on the scene exactly eight months and thirty days after their wedding, and my brother arrived not much later. My dad was living with his sister back then, whom he adored and worshipped. She was really his only friend growing up in the small Ohio town where he was born, and they were inseparable until he met my mom. My dad is a good, decent man. He learned early on that, in the workplace, it is essential not to make waves. He is a writer-- a journalist, and he lost one of his very first jobs for writing a story, not in the usual sports-page style, but in a wildly outlandish, creative style that he had picked up from one of his college English classes(Joyce, Lawrence, Woolf, etc.) After that, he wrote exactly as he was supposed to, expected to, and he has kept his next job(on a local magazine) to this day. I know it hurt him to see other, younger, more flamboyant writers(some of whom he'd actually interviewed and hired) pass him by, especially when he handed out checks on payday and saw that many of theirs were larger. But any gripes or frustrations he may have had disappeared when he sat down at his desk and looked at that picture of my mom and her two boys that stood right next to his IBM Selectric. He ended up writing stories about unsung local heroes, personalities, and eccentrics, and his stories are always voted the most-read items in the magazine each year during the annual reader's poll. Once, he wrote a story about a local kid who had somehow beaten childhood leukemia(through bone marrow transplants from a sibling), and had gone on to represent the country in the steeplechase at the Olympics that year. For that piece, he placed an honorable mention in the Pulitzer awards for magazine journalism, and that certificate still hangs, dusty, proud in the den, alongside all my scholastic awards and my brother's athletic ones. And my mom's trophy, which she won for being on the championship bowling team at our local synagogue. But what I want to tell you about now is what happened one day when I was in junior high school, my brother still in elementary. My dad's sister lay in a hospital bed--throat cancer. We visited her almost daily and my dad was always shaken when we left. I remember we were in the waiting room because a nurse was giving my aunt a sponge-bath when we saw a woman and her young daughter. The mother's face was pretty, but at the moment it was contorted into a scowl, and the fact that her daughter was bopping around noisily, playing 'Got your nose' with me and my brother wasn't helping. Finally, the girl's mother rose and yanked her hard by the arm, dragging her away. "But I'm being good, Mommy. I'm being *good*." "No. You. Are. Not. We're leaving." And we heard the girl scream as they left the hospital. They allowed us to go up to my aunt's room. My mother had stayed at home. She'd lost her own father to cancer two years before, and the memories of that were still too fresh and painful for her to join us. I remember vividly that hospital room: The ever-present beeps and IV bag. The awful smell. My aunt's voice, raspy and hoarse from the cancer that had ravaged her larynx. Her hair thin and crackly from the massive doses of chemo. It seemed incredible to my brother and myself that such a horrid whisper could come from someone whose face was still soft and beautiful. She was too weak to even raise her arms and my dad sat on the edge of the bed and held her hand between his on his lap and leaned close so he could hear her. My brother and I were in charge of rubbing her feet and legs. They always hurt. The visits were very hard for my dad, who is one of the last of the great optimists. Though my aunt could have refused those huge doses of chemotherapy, both she and my father agreed that where there was life there was hope. But when the cancer spread to her lungs and she would cough so hard that we were constantly buzzing for the nurse, we knew that there wasn't any. One day, near the end, my dad leaned in close and we heard her whisper to him, "It shouldn't be like this. No one should be like this. What was ever so bad that it should be like this? What one thing?" When we left the hospital, we saw that it was a beautiful, warm spring day. But for us there was no joy in the clear sky, the pure, clean air, the shouts from the girls in the courtyard behind our apartment. Dinner was especially difficult that night. Despite the news that my brother had finally pulled all A's on a report card, we both knew it would only make things worse to mention it. My mom padded around the kitchen, getting up often to bring things back from the refrigerator that we didn't really need. She touched my father's hand as he picked at his food. It was his favorite, but flavorless tonight. My brother and I both went to bed after dinner, both secretly hoping, in that area behind our thoughts where the truth is found, that she would just stop fighting and go to sleep and not awaken, and that we could have our father back. At about two in the morning I woke up and couldn't fall back to sleep. I made my way into the kitchen and drank some milk. On the way back I heard some sounds from my parents' room. The door was open a crack and father was kneeling at the side of the bed, hands together. I heard his voice crack as he said, "Oh God, God, please. I'm being good. I'm being *so* good. Oh God oh oh God, *please*?" Then I couldn't listen anymore. I slipped back into my room and yanked my brother out of bed. "W-what is it? I'm asleep." I pulled him onto the floor. "No, How, listen. We have to, we have to *pray*."